Untangling Income Tax Withholding

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: the IRS doesn’t see April as tax season - it sees it as “reconciliation”. Understanding the rules and guidelines around income tax withholding is the difference between tax planning and expensive surprises.

It’s the IRS’s World, and We’re Just Living in It

The Internal Revenue Service enforces the federal tax code and collects tax revenue. Like any business, the government prefers a steady, predictable flow of cash rather than a surge leading up to the April filing deadline. The US tax system operates in a “pay as you go” system where you’re expected to pay tax as income is earned or received.

On top of that, the IRS expects you to either pay at least 90% of your current-year tax liability or come within $1,000 of what you ultimately owe. If you take a closer look at a tax return, you’ll see where the tax liability is calculated. Taxes withheld are then deducted from the liability, and credits are applied, resulting in a refund or a balance due.

Without special circumstances, a liability exceeding $1,000 can trigger underpayment penalties. Yes, the IRS charges interest on the balance you owe them! For the first quarter of 2026, the underpayment interest rate is 7% and compounds daily.

Pay-As-You-Go Methods

Most employees work W-2 jobs where taxes are withheld from each paycheck. Employees in this category complete Form W-4, which provides employers with guidance on how much federal income tax to withhold on their behalf. Whether paychecks arrive bi-weekly or semi-monthly, taxes are paid throughout the year, satisfying the pay-as-you-go model.

It’s crucial to file the W-4 accurately. Not sure how to fill out the W-4? The IRS has a Tax Withholding Estimator on its website. Be sure to review the list of required documents before starting, as the tool considers multiple income sources, deductions, and credits.

Retirees, self-employed individuals, and W-2 employees who are under withholding or have other income sources can pay their taxes another way - quarterly estimated tax payments.

Quarterly estimated tax payments are straightforward. The payments are made to the IRS throughout the year to satisfy the pay-as-you-go requirement for any income that is not subject to automatic withholding. This would include self-employment income, investment income, and retirement distributions.

Safe Harbor

It can be tricky for those with inconsistent or non-W-2 income to pay enough during the year to arrive within $1,000 of their final tax bill. That’s where safe harbor rules come into play.

The IRS created safe harbor guidelines that protect taxpayers from underpayment penalties, even if more than $1,000 is owed at tax time. Taxpayers generally qualify for safe harbor protection if they meet one of the following conditions:

• Pay at least 90% of the current year’s tax liability
• Pay 100% of the prior-year liability (or 110% if prior-year adjusted gross income exceeded $150,000)

Taxpayers who make quarterly estimated tax payments often base their payments on the safe-harbor rules. It’s important to work with a tax professional to ensure you’re following the appropriate strategy.

Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments on a Deeper Level

At a high level, quarterly estimated taxes are easy to understand, but there is more complexity under the hood, especially around timing. The first payment is due April 15 for income earned January through March. This is not to be confused with the tax filing deadline for the prior year, which also falls on the same date.

The second quarterly payment is due June 15 and covers income earned in April and May. The third quarterly payment is due September 15 for income earned June through August. The fourth and final payment is due January 15 for income earned September through December.

In March 2025, President Trump signed an Executive Order directing the IRS to modernize payment methods, including a move toward electronic payments. Effective September 25, 2025, the order requires quarterly payments to be made electronically; however, final regulations have not yet been issued.

According to the Taxpayer Advocate Service, enforcement isn’t expected until 2027 or later, so traditional payment methods, such as checks, are likely to remain acceptable. Still, it’s wise to become familiar with online payment options.

The IRS provides two online tools for paying taxes. The first, “IRS Online Account”, requires the establishment of a username and password. Through this account, tax payments can be made as well as providing access to other services and information. Your personal account will maintain up to five years of transaction history.

The second tool for paying taxes is simply through the “Direct Pay” option on the IRS website. You can make an electronic tax payment via a bank account with no processing fee. You also have the option to use a debit/credit card or digital wallet to make the payments, but a transaction fee may apply. This option provides up to 15 months of payment history.

Conclusion

Income tax planning is not something to idle about. Whether you’re a W-2 employee or have multiple streams of income, a little bit of planning goes a long way in warding off surprise tax bills and penalties. There’s no shortage of resources, including the Tax Withholding Estimator, safe harbor rules, and, of course, a quality accountant.

About Us | Get the Bedel Blog | More Tax Planning Articles